Readers Report
I dream of going back. I actually lived at 1010 President Street and before that was on Park Place. Went to P.S. 241 and graduated in 1963. So many people, so many have moved to another location but they have never really left. I am among one or two other things, a writer. I am including a part of my book that is my dream of returning home.
. . .
I still dream about the old neighborhood. Not as much as I used to but time and again it continues to happen. I used to be afraid that this dream would never stop. Now I am afraid that it might. My dreams are clear and vivid. Most often, I am driving down the street and I stop in the middle of the road. I park. Very slowly and very carefully I exit the car. I am afraid. I walk toward my building, very slowly at first, than with more speed. I am fearful and excited to be experiencing this. I feel alive and agitated in a way that is not possible to explain. There are no computer stores. No e-mail. No websites. No couch with seven remotes that I can't understand how to use. I am still walking very slowly. It is like I have been asleep for a long time and I need to come out of that uncomfortable stupor. It is a warm day. The sun is shining. People are coming up to greet me. Some of them I know and some I do not. They are shaking my hand and welcoming me back. They are telling me that everything is all right again as they point to the houses and show off how nice they look and how well they have been kept up. It is almost as if they have done all of this work for me. Because they knew that I was coming for a visit. And if they can get me to stay, they will somehow win. I will win too. I will be able to say
"Look, look how nice everything is. Look how things could have been. We could have stayed right here. We did not have to run away."
They are right. Everything seems so pretty. Immersed in a beauty that can only bee seen by one who wants to see it. It is as though they are trying to show me that nothing has really changed. They worked so very hard just to keep things the same for me. They are showing me that sometimes living in the past is better than living in the present. It is not only for the sad and the malcontent. It is not only for the unhappy and the downtrodden. That there is nothing to feel ashamed about. That my place is still here if I that is what I want because everyone has a right to live where they want to live. To live where they are most happy. To have, if nothing else, no more than they once had but certainly no less. To walk the familiar streets of home.
Somewhere, in the small crowd, a voice rises up and asks me if I am glad to be home. The talking stops. People seem to be waiting for my reply. Some look away as other rub their hands together and cock their heads forward. As though my say-so will somehow make something right again as we correct a wrong that should not have happened. It is almost like the chance to change the universe. To undo something that can't be undone. To beat the system. It is as though these people have worked for years, just for this moment. Just for my answer. I stop my slow walking and think for a moment. It has been so very long. Two marriages long. Three children long. Two gone and one going. Please don't leave me Nick. Please don't leave me alone. Jake, please remember me. Dad loves you Jake. Please come back to me Jake. Many moves long. Many jobs long. An eon has gone by since I have stood in this spot and had the feeling of being home. My eyes burn. I am overwhelmed with what seems to be happening to me. I am home. After so very long, I have finally come home. The endless ache of not belonging is absent and its absence is so very sweet. I am as ordinary and plain as I have ever been and I fit so well into the exact spot that had been taken from me so long ago by those with the very best of intentions. After so many years, I feel connected to the place that has made me what I am. Yes, I am so very glad to be home. I sit on the stoop. It is warm and very hard. I look out at the road as I did as a child and watch the cars go by. I hear Mary Varsi and look to my left. She is trying to find Carmella. I hear Mrs. Rooney call and I look to the right. Michael Lochren is playing in the next yard. Mrs. Rice is at it again, throwing boiling water at the kids for making noise. No matter, she has very bad aim and it cools as it falls from the fourth floor. Joe and M___ have not yet had their three babies die when M___, in a moment of postpartum depression, drowned all of her boys in the bathtub, dressed them in their best clothes and put them to bed while waiting for J___ to come home from work. We were vacationing in Woodburne, NY, vacationing for the summer. My mother read it in the paper. I can still see her crying.
Mrs. Milligan is coming down the stairs, and Mrs. Rice is yelling from her window on the third floor. Mr. Murphy needs me to run to the store and buy him his cigars. For this deed I can collect my nickel and by some candy at Nat's. I turn to my right and the clarity begins to fade. The sun is no longer warm. My right shoulder gives me a bit of pain as it always does in the morning. Rotator cuff surgery has its price and the bill never seems to be paid in full. This is the signal. I turn to look at the people's faces but it is no longer as easy to do as it was before. They are not smiling any longer. They look at me with sadness. They have failed and our respective loss of hope fades quickly. It is time for me to go now. We realize what we all know to be true. That what is factual and reality-based will always win out over what is prayed for and imagined. Their faces tell me that what has been done cannot be undone and there is no way to fix that sad and simple fact. They are as disappointed as I am for they live in a place that I can't ever return to and they can't ever escape from.
The scene begins to fade and the fragile images are replaced by something that moves very slowly. I am feeling very warm under both of these heavy covers. It all begins to disappear very quickly. I am dreaming and I begin to feel the deep sorrow that accompanies the end of this dream. I fall back into the bottom of an early morning sleep that is sweet and quite dreamless. It is without any sensation and beyond any capacity to feel that I exist for that period of time. I awake in an hour or so. I am well rested and strangely content. I have my coffee, kiss my son, fight off my dog, hug my wife and get ready to enter into the life with which I am very pleased and privileged to live.
"Good morning my love," she says. "How did you sleep?" "Fine," I say. "How did you sleep?" "Great," she replies. "Are you gong to see a client today or working at home?" "Actually, I'm going to New York for the day to see someone for Bob." "Good," she says. "I'll review the stuff that has come in over the weekend and get you set up for the week. Is that OK?" "Great," I say. "I'll call you from the road."
My Brooklyn was Crown Heights.
If anyone remembers me or the things I've mentioned, please let in touch. Would love to hear from you.
Readers' reports continue . . .
[ Jump to My Brooklyn, page 1
2 3
4 5
6 7
8 9
10 11
12 13
14 15
16 17
18 19
20 21
22 23
24 25
26 27
28 29
30 31
32 33
34 35
36 37
38 39
40 41
42 43
44 45
46 47
48 49
50 51
52 53
54 55
56 57
58 59
60 61
62 63
64 65
66 67
68 69
70 71
72 73
74 75
76 77
78 79
80 81
82 83
84 85
86 87
88 89
90 91
92 93
94 95
96 97
98 99
100 101
102 103
104 105
106 107
108 109
110 111
112 113
114 115
116 117
118 119
120 121
122 123
124 125
126 127
128 129
130 131
132 133
134 135
136 137
138 139
140 141
142 143
144 145
146 147
148 149
150 151
152 153
154 155
156 157
158 159
160 161
162 163
164 165
166 167
168 169
170 171
172 173
174 175
176 177
178 179
180 181
182 183
184 185
186 187
188 189
190 191
192 193
194 195
196 197
198 199
200 201
202 203
204 205
206 207
208 209
210 211
212 213
214 215
216 217
218 219
220 221
222 223
224 225
226 227
228 229
230 231
232 233
234 235
236 237
238 239
240 241
242 243
244 245
246 247
248 249
250 251
252 253
254 255
256 257
258 259
260 261
262 263
264 265
266 267
268 269
270 271
272 273
274 275
276 277
278 279
280 281
282 283
284 285
286 287
288 289
290 291
292 293
294 295
296 297
298 299
300 301
302 303
304 305
306 307
308 309
310 311
312 313
314 315
316 317
318 319
320 321
322 323
324 325
326 327
328 329
330 331
332 333
334 335
336 337
338 339
340 341
342 343
344 345
346 347
348 349
350 351
352 353
354 355
356 357 358 359 360 361 362 363 364 365 366 367 368]